Could the Colts Still Add to the OL After the 2025 NFL Draft? Exploring Free Agent Options
As the dust settles from the 2025 NFL Draft, the Indianapolis Colts find themselves in a position to reconsider their offensive line (OL) strategies. Despite adding depth with draft picks, the team could benefit from further enhancing the guard position. With several offensive line openings and a moderate salary cap to work with, the Colts may look back to the free agent market.
Current State of the Offensive Line
The Colts have made some moves to fill gaps on their offensive line, particularly with the selection of Jalen Travis, which allows for flexibility in their tackle positions. However, the real challenge lies in transitioning Matt Goncalves from tackle to starting right guard. This shift brings uncertainty; relying solely on a player making a significant position change is a gamble.
Roster Competition is Key
On the current roster, the Colts have a few options at guard, but none provide the stability one might hope for. While Goncalves is a candidate for the right guard role, names like Tanor Bortolini, Atonio Mafi, Josh Sills, and Dalton Tucker offer limited competition. This lack of depth raises concerns about the offensive line’s overall effectiveness, especially with a young quarterback like Anthony Richardson needing a strong pocket.
According to Pro Football Focus (PFF), Richardson completed only 37% of his passes under pressure last season, illustrating the pressing need for a reliable offensive front. Without a solid run game and a clean pocket, the Colts may struggle to find offensive rhythm.
Financial Flexibility to Make a Move
Currently, the Colts enjoy a wage cap space of $23.1 million, providing them with the means to bring in free agent talent without breaking the bank. This financial flexibility presents a strategic opportunity for the Colts to address their offensive line needs effectively.
Top Free Agent Guard Options
Here are some veteran guard options available in the free agent market who could bolster the Colts’ offensive line:
Tyrstan Colon, Arizona
Colon is an intriguing candidate, having played all three interior position spots during his NFL career. In the previous season, he played 10 games and logged 386 snaps. His performance included allowing only 12 pressures and no sacks over 215 pass-blocking reps. His versatility could add value to the Colts’ roster.
Dalton Risner, Minnesota
With a reputation for being a solid pass protector, Risner brings experience to a team in need. In 2024, he allowed just one sack and ranked 40th out of 80 guards in pass-blocking efficiency. However, he did exhibit below-average performance in the run game, which may require consideration for the Colts.
Will Hernandez, Arizona
Although Hernandez played in only five games last season, he brings a strong pass-blocking resume. Since 2022, his pass-blocking grade ranks as the ninth best among all guards, allowing just a 4.2% pressure rate. His affinity for pass protection may serve the Colts well, especially if run-blocking deficiencies can be mitigated.
Brandon Scherff, Jacksonville
Scherff has been a durable option, starting every game in his three years with Jacksonville. He has excelled in pass protection, notably not surrendering a single sack last season. Although his run-blocking grade ranked 57th, his overall effectiveness could still be an asset for the Colts’ offensive scheme.
Conclusion: A Prudent Move for the Colts
In summary, the Indianapolis Colts have a unique opportunity to enhance their offensive line following the 2025 NFL Draft. With the flexibility in their salary cap and key vacancies in the guard position, adding competition through free agency is not just advisable—but necessary.
The looming questions about the capacity of Goncalves and others at guard must be addressed to ensure quarterback Anthony Richardson does not face undue pressure in the pocket. Bringing in any of the aforementioned veteran guards could provide the necessary depth, competition, and ultimately, a more stable offensive line.
As the Colts look to shape their roster, fans and analysts alike will be fascinated to see if the team indeed opts for free agency as a means to solidify their offensive front. What do you think? Should they pursue any of these free agent options? Share your thoughts below!
