Could the Colts Still Add to the OL After the 2025 NFL Draft?
The Indianapolis Colts may have just wrapped up the 2025 NFL Draft, but the team could still bolster its offensive line, specifically at guard. As the Colts eye potential free-agent additions, the question looms: who can they bring in to enhance their roster? With a clear need for depth and competition on the offensive line, the Colts have several intriguing options in the free-agent market.
Assessing the Current Offensive Line Situation
Following this year’s draft, the Colts made a strategic move by selecting Jalen Travis, who adds depth to the tackle position. This decision allows Matt Goncalves, primarily a tackle during his college career, to transition to the right guard position. However, the transition is fraught with uncertainty. Relying solely on Goncalves to fill a starting role could pose risks, as the chemistry and adaptability of new offensive line configurations take time to develop.
Current Roster Options
Currently, the Colts have a few players capable of manning the guard position, including Tanor Bortolini, Danny Pinter, Atonio Mafi, Josh Sills, and Dalton Tucker. While these players offer depth and potential, the lack of fierce competition at right guard raises concerns. Pinter, holding down the center position, has nominal competition, which could hinder the unit’s overall performance.
The Importance of a Strong Offensive Line
With a promising young quarterback like Anthony Richardson, the offensive line’s performance becomes crucial. Last season, Richardson completed just 37% of his passes under pressure, while Daniel Jones managed only 44%. A reliable offensive line is fundamental for providing a clean pocket and establishing a steady run game, essential for offensive success.
Free-Agent Guard Options for the Colts
With over $23.1 million in available cap space, the Colts are well-positioned to make impactful free-agent signings without breaking the bank. Here are a few veteran guards who could compete for a starting role:
Tyrstan Colon, Arizona
Tyrstan Colon has played all three interior positions during his NFL career, making him a versatile asset for any team. Last season, he appeared in 10 games, logging 386 snaps and excelling as a run-blocker. Notably, he allowed just 12 pressures and no sacks, making him a solid candidate for the Colts’ offensive line.
Dalton Risner, Minnesota
Dalton Risner has consistently performed well in pass protection throughout his career. In 2024, he allowed only one sack and was ranked 40th out of 80 guards in pass-blocking efficiency. Although Risner’s run-blocking metrics fell short, his experience and skill set can bring depth to the Colts’ offensive line.
Will Hernandez, Arizona
Although Will Hernandez appeared in just five games last season, his performance since 2022 has been impressive. His pass-blocking grade ranks ninth among all guards during that span. With a pressure rate allowed of only 4.2%, Hernandez’s track record indicates his effectiveness in pass protection, making him a valuable option for the Colts.
Brandon Scherff, Jacksonville
Brandon Scherff has been a model of durability, participating in all games during his three seasons in Jacksonville. As a seasoned right guard, he demonstrated exceptional pass protection; last season, he did not allow a single sack, ranking fourth among his position group in PFF’s pass-blocking efficiency metric. Despite ranking 57th in run-blocking, his value in pass protection is undeniable.
Conclusion: A Strategic Move for Success
As the Indianapolis Colts navigate the post-draft landscape, adding to their offensive line remains a pressing concern, particularly at the guard position. Transitioning Matt Goncalves to right guard poses inherent risks, making the acquisition of experienced free-agent options a prudent strategy. With several viable candidates still available, the Colts have the financial flexibility to enhance their roster significantly.
The importance of a strong offensive line cannot be overstated, especially with a young quarterback like Richardson at the helm. By investing in proven veterans, the Colts have an opportunity to solidify their offensive line, ensuring both immediate competitiveness and long-term success.
What are your thoughts on the Colts’ needs for the offensive line? Do you think they should pursue any of the free agents mentioned? Share your opinions in the comments below!
